Many people have asked why I split from the TRC (Trasgender Resource Centre) and started my own trangender support venue in SecondLife. I have been accused of a lot of things, my friends have been harassed and plenty of rumors about me, my lifestyle and my loved ones have caused no end of hurt and pain.
I will just let Ashley Lynch’s own words vindicate my position. This is pulled straight from her own blog. Ashley Lynch is the co-director of the TRC and as such, her views on the transgendered community in SecondLife are of vital importance to the community that organisation claims to represent.
There is a real tendency, especially in the online community, but as a whole for transgendered people to use their gender identity and status as a discriminated class as a crutch to elevate their other issues. Many trans people find themselves latched onto some very strange fantasy ideas and fetish communities in their effort to explore their identity. The end result is people who will defend their “hobbies” to the death as a core part of who they are and demand mass social acceptance for them.
People being led around on leashes in public with their hands bound and saying “Yes Mistress” constantly who assert that to tell them to not be submissive is like telling them not to be trans. People who claim to be infantile preteen children and will debate until the end of time how it is a legitimate identity that must be accepted just like their gender identity. (I’m not kidding.) And no, you are not supposed to be a child in an adult body. That’s a mental issue you need to be seeking therapy for, it is not an identity. You were a child once, but it’s over now, let it go! And while we’re on the topic, let’s talk about furries. You were not meant to be born as a humanoid half fox, half cat. No one has the genetic makeup for interspecies DNA. Your mother was human, your father was human. You’re human! Even if your dad fucked a horse, it would still never result in a furry. Being furry is not an identity that you need to fight for to have social acceptance. You know why? Cause it’s a fetish, plain and simple. Sexual or no, it’s a fetish.
The even greater damage that gets done here is that transgenderism already gets viewed way too much as something sexual or fetishistic. Having BDSM neko trans girls hanging around only help to perpetuate that stereotype and work against creating a proactive atmosphere for trans people everywhere. Some of us are trying to reverse negative stereotypes and get laws and rights passed for all of us to make the world a better place for all transgendered people.
So just because you’re adamant that all these messed up hobbies of yours (and I’m not judging, I have my own messed up hobbies) are an intrinsic part of your identity, every bit as much as your gender really doesn’t make it so. To be painfully blunt (and why stop now), this is merely a roleplaying fantasy that you’ve taken to extreme levels and tried to secure a thinly built connection in attempts to bootstrap it into legitimacy. ie. You are delusional and either need a reality check or a councilor. I know I’m being extremely judgmental and it’s okay. People who indulge in this sort of activity need a slap in the face to get some perspective. I’m not saying don’t have your messed up hobbies. I’m sure it’s fun. But don’t expect me or the rest of society to accept you as anything other than a comical farce if you try and take those hobbies into public. There’s a time and a place.
You can read her full post in its original context here.
The Transgender Lounge’s founding principle is “Supporting gender diversity through tolerance” and its very obvious from the statement above why such an organisation is so desperatly needed in SecondLife.
The Transgender Lounge is located next door to the TRC and EVERYONE will always be welcome.







I’ve posted this comment to Ashley’s blog, but I just want to add that those are her own personal opinions. I am pretty pissed off with all of this division all round really, and I don’t think that Ash’s post was helpful. By the same token, I’m not particularly happy with a big frigging sign of 10 metres or more being floated over the TGL to shout to TRC members that you’re there too. Talk about caught in the crossfire! I spent plenty on my land too dear, and you go sticking something as bad as an ad farm to overshadow my nice cottage that is also next door to TRC. A plague upon both your houses, to quote a bit of Shakespeare.
I have my own issues on BDSM stuff, and broadly speaking I am not a fan. On this issue, I just leave people to get on with that theirselves. The Transgender Resource Centre recently drew a line on people being in slave poses, on leashes, doing the yes master/mistress thing in the TRC. That makes sense in the centre, as it is something that is threatening or offputting to others, and should be put to one side when people are in the support environment.
On the child avatar thing, again it made sense to ask people to not use a child avatar in the centre. That was because people could be talking about adult matters, including sexual relationships, and someone in full child roleplay is not really appropriate at that time.
Other than my personal distaste for dom/sub stuff, I think that people can do what they like in SL and RL, but should keep it out of support venues, and perhaps some other places. The same goes for kid avatars, but I don’t have any objection to child roleplay, particularly in child orientated places. I used a child AV for a short while when I first joined SL, because I thought that it would stop guys hitting on me and because I am a big kid and I like being silly. No harm in that, and for me I don’t want to go into full roleplay. However, I don’t really have a problem with those that do. If they have issues from their childhood and find that roleplay theraputic, then good luck to them.
As for furries, people dress up in a fantasy creature suit, and it’s not really all that different from Mr or Mrs Couldn’t-Run-A-Mile being a guy with huge muscles or a woman being a leggy slender blonde. That’s fantasy and it doesn’t do any harm. In settings like the TRC, I don’t think that it’s disruptive, and I don’t have a problem with that. Lots of people spend hours playing violent video games, and I’ve even seen someone spend hours team-killing their colleagues for the kick of it. That’s a whole lot less constructive than somebody being a furry and socialising with other people on SL.
For me, I’m fundamentally a libertarian, but there always has to be a line drawn as to where some things are appropriate.
Analise
Inclusiveness, Yay?
I truly prefer the atmosphere of an inclusive group whose leaders don’t
suppose to have the monopoly on what TS Identity is supposed to be.
And really, I’m quite tired of “Benjamin Transgenders”
GET OFF IT! That guy was operating out of a position of ignorance and I would almost say a fetishistic approach of his own… and it sickens me when smart transgender people subscribe to his specific pathology of ignorance.
Anyhow, I’ll support a group that is more inclusive than exclusive any day as I’m really quite tired of people trying to put themselves above others because of personal preferences or lifestyle choices.